View from the South – Birmingham City v Reading

Nice to read a happy report from Bazza, things are looking up! 🙂

It was a crisp clear morning as I walked down towards the station. I was beginning to wonder whether I had put enough warm clothing on but it was too late now and I would just have to get myself an impromptu Christmas present at the shop later if necessary. I met a young lady on the station whose accent I recognised. It turned out that she had been brought up in Yardley and had gone to school at Sheldon Heath Comprehensive, a stone’s throw away from where I used to live in Garretts Green. She was a bluenose to boot; it truly is a small world. We spent a pleasant 20 minutes, reminiscing about areas and places familiar to us both before going our separate ways.

What then didn’t help was the connecting train to New Street slipping gradually ever later coming in over 25 minutes late. This meant I was going to miss my connection to get the Lichfield train to visit my elderly aunt and cousin in Four Oaks and therefore be very tight for time. Picture if you will the Nativity scene of Joseph and Mary traipsing through the snow in a red hot country; you know the one don’t you? Well I was the donkey carrying two heavy bags of Christmas gifts and other kit that weighed about as much as the gravid virgin did and altogether a morning that had started off reasonably well was now going decidedly pear shaped (like the gravid Virgin in a way 🙂 )

I didn’t get back to New Street much before 2 pm and Chris fought through the pre Christmas traffic in town to pick me up along Digbeth opposite the Coach Station and it meant we had time for a quick pint in the Royal George before a turkey and stuffing bap in the ground with further refreshment.

Never in my wildest dreams did I expect that the game was going to pan out in the way that it did. On three minutes Blues were awarded a free kick on the edge of the area and everyone including me expected Cotterill to attempt a left footed curler into the top corner to the goalkeeper’s left. A smart square pass to Paul Caddis from Jonathan Grounds instead was dispatched into the bottom left hand corner for 1-0. Reading threatened from that set back and should have equalised virtually immediately with a shot from Simon Cox that fortunately was fired straight at Randolph and the keeper preserved our lead with another save not long after. In the first ten minutes, four crosses into our box were won in the air by Reading attackers with second balls going their way as well. Reading could and should have had three quick fire goals before Gray scored the first of his excellent treble with a right footed shot across the keeper from a defence splitting pass from Shinnie on 11 minutes.

My feeling was that despite the 2-0 score line the better football was being played by the visitors and it was no surprise when yet another cross from Jordan Obita that should have been cut out was finally converted by Glen Murray with a looping header past the stranded Randolph for a goal Reading richly deserved.

I feared the worst and thought that the way things were going that Reading would restore parity; such was their control of the game; and increased confidence. Sadly for the visitors, and happily for us, Gray had other ideas as he added his second and Blues’ third on 20 minutes following a poor touch by Jake Cooper which allowed Gray to skip round him and fire across Federici into the bottom corner and a fourth in time added on following a quick break by David Davis who waited for and fed in a well weighted pass for the youngster to complete his hat trick for a 4-1 lead that although welcome seemed barely believable on the balance of play. Had the score been 1-4 in their favour, few would have argued. Don’t get me wrong Blues were fabulous going forward but atrocious at the back ,and the differences between the teams were that Reading’s defending was even worse, and we took our chances and they didn’t.

The second half, Blues were a lot tighter but the thing that killed the game for the visitors was a stunning strike from Andrew Shinnie who had it not been for Gray’s wonderful hat trick would on any other day have claimed the man of the match status. What a transformation in fortunes for this young man since the arrival of Gary Rowett! It just goes to show what can be achieved when a manager gets the best out of players that didn’t look as if they could win against a bunch of five year olds a few short weeks back. Shinnie showed great intelligence and movement to find himself down the inside right position going towards the byline. Caddis and Cotterill carved out the opening to feed Shinnie in. He was allowed far too much latitude to turn inside and fire a left footed shot inside the near post for 5-1.

The stuff of dreams was this and just around the hour mark Blues were awarded a free kick wide on the left flank which David Cotterill stepped up to take with his right foot. Just occasionally I get a premonition that a certain event is going to happen and just before he took it I said “go on son swing it to the far post it might just go in anyway!” Well knock me down with a feather, that is exactly what happened as the Tilton had a close up view of its second and Blues’ sixth goal of the afternoon.

It could have been a seventh not long after when Clayton Donaldson’s shot was well saved by the Reading keeper not long after. Reading were a defeated, demoralised force at this stage but to their credit carried on trying to play football even at 6-1 down and should have had a consolation second goal in the last few minutes when a ball that should have been cleared was allowed to stay in play at the byline. The cut back was perfect, the finish by Murray was against the bar, and as a Reading supporter you know it is not your day!

A really funny thing happened on 80 minutes when Reading wanted to make their final substitution, the announcer said “COMING ON FOR BLACKPOOL!” This was greeted with much merriment and mirth and chants of “Are we Blackpool in disguise?” from the visiting support. The faithful around me were in very good voice by now and as Nikola Zigic joined the fray to much rejoicing it was instantaneously replaced by good natured abuse of the type we used to give him; “Jump! You lazy b*****r! “They’re paying you how much?” and the like, amid much laughter.

Frankly, I try not to read too much into freak scores like this. Seriously, does this mean that Birmingham City have become world beaters? No, definitely not. Does it mean that Reading are a poor team? On the contrary, I felt that they were perversely the better team in the first half but they found themselves on the wrong end of a 4-1 score line; it could so easily have been the same score the other way or 4-4. We rode our luck in defence and we were clinical in attack and that was the difference. Don’t be deceived, Blues have to defend better against Derby when they come to St Andrews on Boxing Day. Nevertheless, well done Birmingham on a superb performance at least in an attacking sense. Defensively? There is a lot of work to do though we were far better in the second half.

The Good: The hat trick from Demarai Gray. Excellent composure from the young man. I hope and I pray that we won’t be forced to sell him in January to a ‘big’ club for his development to go backwards in the reserve eleven of a so-called ‘elite’ team. How many talents have we seen wasted like this especially when they immediately get loaned out to one of our direct rivals? Andrew Shinnie’s performance; take a bow son! The appearance of Nikola Zigic for the last ten minutes; welcome back Ziggy!

The Bad: the defending from both sides! Make no mistake, it is only out of good fortune that we only conceded one goal in the first half. The Reading defending was absolutely shocking; I’m just glad that we were the recipients of such profligacy for once.

The Ugly: Chris’s Decembeard!!!!! Roll on January! 😀

Birmingham City: Darren Randolph 8, Paul Caddis 8, Michael Morrison 7, Paul Robinson 7, Jonathan Grounds 8, Stephen Gleeson 7, David Davies 8, Andrew Shinnie 8 (Guy Moussi 78, 7) Demarai Gray 9 (Wes Thomas 88, N/A) David Cotterill 8, Clayton Donaldson 7 (Nikola Zigic 83, N/A).

Subs not used: Colin Doyle, David Edgar, Callum Reilly, Lee Novak.

Goals: Caddis 4, Gray 11, 24, 45 + 1 Shinnie 46 Cotterill 60.

Bookings: None

Reading: Adam Federici 6, Stephen Kelly 5 Jake Cooper 5 Michael Hector 5 (Alex Pearce 66, 6) Chris Gunter 5 Garath McCleary 5 Oliver Norwood 5 Daniel Williams 5 (Jake Taylor 80, N/A) Jordan Obita 6 (Nick Blackman 75, 6) Simon Cox 6, Glenn Murray 6.

Subs not used: Aaron Tshibola, Jack Stacey, Mikkel Andersen, Shaun Cummings.

Goals: Murray 19.

Bookings: Gunter, Hector.

Referee: Nigel Miller 6: Very strange performance from the man in the middle. I cannot for the life of me understand why he seemed to have a determination to never give a decision in Clayton Donaldson’s favour. The bloke was continually pushed, pulled, manhandled and at times assaulted and yet I can only remember one free kick being given against the Reading defenders regarding Donaldson and that was in the 72nd minute. Arguably, he let the game flow but the referee’s performance was indifferent at best.

Attendance: 15,240.

Discuss this post, and other items, in the Joys and Sorrows Forum.


11 Comments on View from the South – Birmingham City v Reading

  1. well written bazza you summed it about right going forward reading looked good but they defended
    like we did against or lose Gary rowett has put a smile back on us noses.

  2. Yes, he has Nicko and long may it continue 😀 I think the main thing that Gary Rowett has achieved is that he has organised the team and made them know their jobs. There is a clear game plan and some logic in the substitutions when they are made. How far he can take us with the present squad remains to be seen but I think we all have to stay grounded and realistic. There are going to be games this season when we don’t play well and there will be poor results at some stage; that is when we will know the real value of our new manager and the quality of the present players.

  3. I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who thought our defending was shocking, too many people getting carried away with the 6-1 result. Reading’s defence was absolutely appalling and as you say we were the lucky recipients.
    Give Rowett credit though, second half he pushed the full backs wide to stop the crosses and pushed Davies and Gleeson higher up onto their midfield.
    Looks like we have a lucky manager something you couldn’t say about Lee Clark.

  4. Very good report as usual Bazza, very much how I saw the game. The fact that Reading never gave up and, indeed, had more of the possession, made the game very interesting. Blues continue to show tremendous improvement and look a far more confident team than a few weeks ago. The transformation of Shinnie’esta is unbelievable and David Davies had an excellent game. The only exception to all this, was the performance of Jonathon Grounds, who I felt, failed to close the winger down and on one occasion in the second half, allowed the Reading defender to run past him, cross the ball ,from which, they hit the bar. Maybe i’m being picky and i’m sure Gary Rowett will be well up to speed, with any problems. All in all though, an enjoyable afternoons entertainment.

  5. Yes John, I confess to being very concerned especially in the first twenty minutes about the crosses not being stopped at source. Glenn Murray and Simon Cox were winning everything in our box when the ball came in and with a little more run of the ball could have caused us problems before we scored our second. Jonathan Grounds hopelessly misjudged the ball on the byline that allowed the lad in to cross. He was trying to shepherd the ball out but it never had enough pace on it to go over the line. I cannot understand why players don’t just deal with it sometimes and hoof it out for a throw in. If the ball is off the pitch the opposition can’t score! Simples!

    I also agree with John Ramsey when he says we appear to have a lucky manager; indeed it was Napoleon Bonaparte that said, “I would rather have a General that was lucky than one that was good!”

  6. Still getting over the shock tbh! Thanks for posting on the Tilehurst End with your comments, and attempting to make us feel better about our team!

    Our trouble is that Adkins plays possession football, but we do absolutely nothing with it. Because of Anton Zingaravich’s aborted takeover of the club, we nearly went broke, and even now under new ownership are still reaping the disaster of AZs tenure, with wages for people such as Pavel Pogrebnyak and Royston Drenthe crippling the club. The upshot is that we couldn’t afford to buy a defender, so we are using Cooper and Hector, both academy prospects (Pearce was utter garbage in our defeat at Cardiff, and has been dropped since). We then play a right back (Gunter) at left back, as we haven’t got a left back. Strange thing then..we aren’t great at defending. Can’t think why!

    However, all that said, we have a decent squad, who should be challenging for the play offs, not 16th. Hence the reason that about 90% of the fans (esp after Saturday) want to see the back of Nigel Adkins.

    Anyway, good luck for the rest of your season (bar one game in Berkshire of course 🙂 )

  7. Thanks Gwent Royal for your comments. Playing raw recruits and people out of normal position sounds all too familiar. Our last manager played a full back in midfield, a centre half at full back, a defensive midfielder in the other full back berth and there were at least two other positional changes that we could only describe as insane. Needless to say, Blackburn Rovers whom we were playing were four up at half time. That was the time I decided that Lee Clark had to go. We were so lucky to escape relegation and we would undoubtedly have gone this season had it not been for a change at the top. At least now we have hope again. I don’t think we will necessarily pull up trees but we should be OK in mid table I reckon. Good luck for the rest of your season (bar one game in Berkshire of course 🙂 )

  8. great rounded report again bazza as usual…nice touch with the post on oppositions website …hope all have a great xmas ..look forward to next posts …merry xmas and happy new year

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.